🔗 Share this article

During a warm evening in the southern part of Mexico, a rhythm group employing water bottles as devices directs a parade through the city of Mérida, capital of the Yucatán region. Kids marching alongside senior citizens are led by activists of a Maya land rights organization. The placards they hold declare: “Water should not be commercialized.” A heavy slogan accompanies the march: “It’s not a drought – it's exploitation!”

Growing Worries About Mega-Projects

In a rallying point in the city, activists share from a declaration and criticize the government of prioritising revenue over water security, well-being and territory. They condemn a series of industrial initiatives introduced without their approval, from large pork production facilities to the contentious tourist railway development initiative. But they save their greatest anger for the beer production plant in Kanasín, near the city, which was revealed in June.

The main ingredient in beer is water. They are still taking a lot out to make the product … huge quantities a day

For numerous of local residents, the proposals for the industrial facility are seen not as a promising initiative, but as a continuation of a underlying problem: of government-backed commercial projects that threaten water supplies and human rights, leaving indigenous groups caught in an unfair conflict to protect their traditional and natural way of life.

Resource Extraction and Environmental Consequences

Under a $2.75bn funding initiative, the brewing plant is expected to produce 2,500 jobs, in various roles, including several hundred long-term jobs. Indigenous communities have challenged a absence of local approval – disputing the corporation's assertion that discussions took place in winter – and expressing apprehensions about its ecological effects, particularly the implications of its resource extraction on local communities.

“It endangers our water supply through pollution, but could make it harder for low-income residents to use it,” says a community representative, an spokesperson with the advocacy group.

Kanasín sits inside the region's underground aquifer network, a system of underground aquifers of traditional and practical significance to the local communities and an important resource of fresh water. Multiple studies have recorded pollution from development projects within the cenote water supply.

Brewery Claims and Local Distrust

Heineken says it will manufacture 400m litres of beverage a year, and aims to restrict water consumption to a specific amount for every litre of product. But a calculation estimates this could mean losing huge quantities of water at the current rate of more water for every unit of brew.

Advocates say this is enough water to support numerous homes in a region where about 121,000 people were without availability to clean water in recent years, and resource access has decreased by more than a significant percentage since 2003. Various studies have also commented that in some villages of Mexico, alcohol is more easily accessible than potable water.

Industrial operations have a record of stating they will treat the wastewater using the modern methods to prevent toxins, but then they neglect to

The brewery also claims its proposed facility will lower its water consumption with “circular economy methods that ensure water re-use through modern cleaning technology” and plans to limit residue and operate using renewable energy.

Expert Perspectives and Previous Cases

However an industry expert, operator of a local brewing company, says this is inadequate. A large portion of the liquid used to clean production tanks can be reused, he says, but the huge capacity of the brewery's output inevitably makes it thirsty.

“Beer is primarily water; they will withdraw a lot out to make the product. This amounts to huge volumes a day,” he says. The pressure on aquifers, the brewer says, is “less about the reuse, and focused on the direct withdrawal of aquifer resources to manufacture at that size.”

Local groups are also concerned about pollution. Industrial production facilities are obligated by law to process wastewater produced during the brewing process, as it holds significant amounts of chemicals and biological elements that can harm earth and taint underground resources.

Uc Be voices apprehension about adherence. “Regrettably, these companies have a history of stating they will clean the wastewater using the newest methods to stop pollution, but then they do not.”

Legal Actions and Indigenous Opposition

Due to inadequate government representation, some Maya groups have turned to the legal system for assistance. In the summer, several populations demanded a halt on new massive pork production facilities; although the request did not succeed, similar legal actions resulted in the termination of an operation and penalties for 26 others.

Last year, in a legal proceeding that is still ongoing, a advocacy network filed a legal action against the state to secure legal personhood for the cenote network.

However judicial processes is costly and can take years to resolve. By the time courts supported community appeals to stop work on segments of the Maya Train in January, the infrastructure had already been constructed.

The representative says he does not know what the group will do next. “We lack a way to prevent the initiative right now. It's an enormous obstacle,” he says.

Heritage {Survival|Pres